The 5th Avenue Theatre Reviews

The 5th Avenue Theatre has an overall rating of 2.8 based on 32 reviews. Customer feedback on The 5th Avenue Theatre is mixed.

2.8/5.0

32 reviews

5 Stars

5

4 Stars

7

3 Stars

6

2 Stars

5

1 Star

9

All The 5th Avenue Theatre Reviews (32)
hello_teresa584
June 02, 2026
"Good snacks, but the prices are ridiculous"
The concessions were good, so I’ll give them that. The snacks tasted fresh, the drinks were cold, and the popcorn was actually better than I expected. But the prices were way too high for what you get, and that’s on them. It feels like they know people don’t have many other options, so they just charge whatever they want. Service was quick and the place was clean, but I was still annoyed walking away with such an overpriced bill
Rita_mefford05
May 29, 2026
"The parking was fine overall ..."
The parking was fine overall , but it could definitely be easier to figure out ...
Robert-kim
May 28, 2026
"A little pricey, but it’s fine"
The tickets felt a bit more expensive than I expected, but you know, it’s fine. Totally fine. I still went and had a decent time, I just wish the price had been a little easier to justify.
Charles_walker81
May 11, 2026
"I mostly checked out The 5th..."
I mostly checked out The 5th Avenue Theatre because I was curious about the historic architecture stuff. Some of it was actually interesting, and I liked looking through the details on the old buildings. The site itself felt a little plain though, and it wasn’t the easiest to click around and find things. It did help me find a few things, so that was good, but yeah, overall it was okay. Not bad, just kind of okay and could definitely be a bit better
Harrison_jones84
May 06, 2026
"I really wanted to enjoy the dance..."
I really wanted to enjoy the dance parts, but they just didn’t click. The choreography felt kind of messy and dull, and after a while I was wondering, what am I even supposed to be looking at? It was hard to watch and didn’t add much for me.
hello_james420
May 05, 2026
"Felt ignored"
Stopped in expecting a normal, easy visit. Didn’t really get that. The staff barely acknowledged me, and when they did, it felt kind of cold. No real friendliness, no welcoming vibe. I mostly just felt ignored the whole time.
Richard_mcmurry80
April 06, 2026
"Just a weird feeling in there"
I don’t know, I just didn’t really feel good being inside this place. It had this cold kind of vibe, like not cozy or welcoming how I thought it might be, and I felt sort of awkward sitting there.
The music was loud in some areas in a strange way, and the layout felt all over the place to me. I ended up leaving fast because it just wasn’t a spot I wanted to keep hanging out in.
harryshea3423
April 04, 2026
"Pretty disappointing show"
I was let down by the show. It felt messy the sound was off and by the end I was just wishing I hadn’t spent the money
Katherine-rhoades
March 23, 2026
"I took the train and just walked a..."
I took the train and just walked a few minutes from there, so it was really easy. I didn’t have to deal with parking or sit in traffic, which was a huge plus. being able to get there by public transit was the best part for me
james2001
March 12, 2026
"Accessible seats were good, but booking took a while"
The accessible seats ended up being good, and the staff did help us get settled, so that part was fine. It wasn’t like they went way above and beyond, but they were polite and made sure the seating situation worked, which I appreciated. The main thing was that the booking process felt kind of slow. It took longer than I expected, and I had to be a bit patient with it, but once we actually got there, the seating itself was okay and everything worked out
kathleen_Valenzuela99
March 11, 2026
"Costumes felt cheap and distracting"
I was expecting a lot more from the costume design, but it felt messy. Some of the outfits looked cheap and didn’t really fit the scenes, which pulled me out of the experience.

A few costumes seemed like they belonged in completely different shows. I kept feeling like there should’ve been clearer direction or instructions behind the overall look, because it just didn’t feel consistent.

For the ticket price, I thought everything would look more polished and put together. I really wanted to enjoy it more, but the costumes were distracting and left me disappointed.
molly1985
March 06, 2026
"The lighting looked decent overall, but a few..."
The lighting looked decent overall, but a few spots felt WAY too dim for my taste. It wasn’t bad or anything, I just expected the whole space to feel a little more balanced.
jamesbradish5390
March 04, 2026
"Box office made fixing my ticket easy"
I accidentally picked the wrong date when buying my tickets, so I called the box office expecting it to be a whole thing. It really wasn’t. The person who answered was calm and patient, even while I was double-checking the date and squinting at the confirmation email like it was a puzzle. They switched it over quickly and didn’t make me feel awkward about the mistake. No bouncing me around, no long explanation, just a simple fix. I especially appreciated it because it was before a busy show night and I was already a little stressed
WILMOT
March 01, 2026
"Pretty good overall, but I expected a better price"
I’ve been using it for a bit and it’s decent overall. It does what I expected for the most part, but for the monthly subscription price, I was hoping for a little more value. Not a bad option, just feels slightly higher than it should be
thomas1972
February 28, 2026
"Solid legroom, didn’t feel packed in"
Booked through The 5th Avenue Theatre the legroom was legit. I’m kinda tall, so I can tell real quick when a seat feels cramped, but this one wasn’t bad at all. I could stretch out a bit and sit normally the whole ride. It’s a small thing, but yeah, it made the trip way more comfy.
DUDENHOEFFER
February 20, 2026
"Seats get uncomfortable after a bit"
The seats felt cramped, and after sitting for a while, my back was really sore. It was not the most comfortable experience.
virginiatoledo6491
February 20, 2026
"Save your time: it feels low budget"
The site does work, so I’ll give it that, but the whole thing feels kind of low budget. Some of the pages look outdated, and the visuals just don’t feel polished. I was expecting something a bit more professional, so if presentation matters to you, save your time and keep your expectations low.
dwayne_Jackson86
February 13, 2026
"Concession Prices Felt Reasonable"
The concession prices seemed fair overall. I went in expecting the usual overpriced snacks, but from the vibe and how everything was priced, it felt like they were trying to keep things reasonable...
bertha_Chapa05
February 05, 2026
"Pretty easy site to use overall"
I spent a little time using 5thavenue.org, it was easy to figure out. The pages loaded fine for me, and I didn’t feel like I had to dig around forever just to find the basic info I needed.
The only thing I noticed — not a huge deal — is that some sections could be a bit clearer. The layout feels a little plain in spots, but overall, it does what it needs to do, and I didn’t run into any major issues
ElliottDuggar
February 01, 2026
"Usher really wasn’t helpful"
I didn’t have the best experience here because the usher was no help at all. I asked where I was supposed to go and they just pointed in a rude way then walked off. It felt like I was bothering them just by asking a simple question. For a place like this I expected at least basic help but that didn’t happen. Disappointing

View More Reviews

Have a question about The 5th Avenue Theatre?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.